How to choose an English saddle that fits both of you

A saddle that fits the horse but pinches you is a bad buy, and so is the reverse. Here is how to shop for the one piece of tack that has to work for two bodies at once.

Some links in this article are affiliate links; Apex Equine may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

A saddle is the most expensive mistake most riders make twice. The first time you buy on looks and a good deal; the second time, after your horse starts pinning his ears at the mounting block, you buy on fit. Skip the first round.

Start with the horse, because he can't return his half of the deal. A saddle has to clear the withers with three fingers of space when you're mounted, sit level so you're not tipped onto your fork or sliding to the cantle, and distribute weight evenly down the panels without bridging or rocking. When Diane at Larkspur Farm put her new warmblood Otis into a medium-wide tree that was really built for a Thoroughbred, the points dug in behind his shoulder blades and within a month he was hollowing his back through every downward transition. A reputable saddle fitter solved it in one visit. Before you buy anything, learn what your horse's back actually needs, because a saddle that bridges across his loin causes the same kind of soreness that no amount of a fancy saddle pad and when to use them will paper over.

Then fit yourself. Seat size is measured from the stud button to the center of the cantle, and most adults land between 17 and 18 inches; if your seat slides back and your thigh hangs off the front of the flap, you're in the wrong size no matter what the tag says. The twist (the width of the saddle where it sits between your thighs) matters more than people expect. A narrow twist suits a rider with less hip width; a wider twist that feels like sitting on a picnic table will ache after twenty minutes. Sit in as many as you can. Dover Saddlery's used consignment wall is a cheap classroom: spend an afternoon in a dozen used English saddles and you'll learn what your own body likes faster than any chart will teach you.

Discipline drives the flap. A close-contact jumping saddle has a forward flap to accommodate a shorter stirrup; a dressage saddle has a long, straight flap and deep seat for a longer leg. An all-purpose saddle splits the difference and is the honest choice for a lesson rider or a one-horse owner who hacks, jumps a little, and schools on the flat. Bates and Wintec build adjustable-gullet models that let you change the tree width with a tool kit, which is genuinely useful for a growing young horse or a barn that shares saddles; you can find the Wintec and Bates adjustable saddles across most major retailers.

New leather is wonderful and expensive. A well-kept used saddle from a quality maker — Stubben, County, Black Country — will outride a cheap new synthetic and hold its resale value if you buy a recognizable brand. If budget is the deciding factor, a synthetic from a brand like Thorowgood is honest, washable tack that fits real horses; Riding Warehouse keeps a deep synthetic saddle selection worth comparing before you spend four figures on leather you don't need yet.

Whatever you settle on, build a trial into the deal. Any seller worth your money will let you ride in the saddle for a week, or send a fitter to confirm it on your horse before the check clears. A few practical rules from years of watching people get this right and wrong:

Ride in it at the trot and canter, not just the walk in the parking lot. Problems with balance and twist only show up once the horse is moving and you're posting. Check the billets and stitching on anything used; new billets cost forty dollars but a billet failing over a fence costs a lot more. And once it's home, protect the investment with proper conditioning — a tin of Effax or a good leather balm, kept in your kit alongside the rest of your gear; most riders grab a basic leather care set and forget it on the shelf, which is how a thousand-dollar seat ends up cracked at the gullet in five winters.

Once the saddle is sorted, the bridle is the next thing people overspend on without measuring; if you're outfitting a horse from scratch, get the bridle fit and styles right before you order, because a too-big browband and a flapping noseband undo the polished look you just paid for. A saddle that fits is quiet. The horse stops bracing, you stop gripping, and you suddenly have the attention to actually ride.